Screen Robot
  • Movie News
  • TV News
  • Gaming
    • Xbox Games
  • Streaming
    • Netflix
    • Amazon Prime
    • Now TV
    • Disney Plus
  • Trailers
  • Screen News
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Screen Robot
  • Movie News
  • TV News
  • Gaming
    • Xbox Games
  • Streaming
    • Netflix
    • Amazon Prime
    • Now TV
    • Disney Plus
  • Trailers
  • Screen News
No Result
View All Result
Screen Robot
No Result
View All Result

Disney should quit live action and get back to what it knows

Rachel Carlyon by Rachel Carlyon
10th September 2013
in Movie News
18 1
0
Disney should quit live action and get back to what it knows
36
SHARES
143
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Lone Ranger. Alice In Wonderland. John Carter. Walt wouldn’t be pleased.

You may remember The Lone Ranger: it was released a few weeks ago. There was a bit of publicity, people said it was shit and it kind of vanished. The Lone Ranger’s lifespan was so short, its visit to cinemas so fleeting, that you’d be forgiven for forgetting its existence. It’s the latest in a line of Disney live action flops that go to show that a big production name and a gigantic budget don’t always equal a success.

The Lone Ranger has been likened to John Carter, although people actually remember John Carter, if only when compiling worst of 2012 lists

The Lone Ranger has been likened to last year’s John Carter (although people actually still remember John Carter, even if only when compiling lists of the worst films of 2012). You would have thought that Disney would have learnt its lesson and avoided the ‘epic summer blockbuster’ path for a little longer, to at least give audiences time to forget its disastrous attempt at it last year. But it would seem that it hasn’t, and has once again created a vapid, two-and-a-half-hour long special effects fest for audiences and critics to rip to shreds. The Lone Ranger had the traditional right ingredients for a success: big name stars, financial backing…but there’s still something Disney lacks when it comes to creating successful live action films.

So why can’t Disney handle live action? By the studio’s own admission, a lot of the failure could boil down to poor marketing. Disney’s executive vice president in charge of marketing, Dave Hollis, said that they’d “hoped [The Lone Ranger] would connect with a broader audience,” after numbers showed that 68% of ticket buyers were over 25 years old and almost 25% over 50, much higher than the average for the studio.

the lone ranger depp

Perhaps Disney is forgetting that its main audience is still primarily children. Of course, there is a crossover, more so now than in the past, with the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise and even Pixar reaching out to wider age ranges, but The Lone Ranger’s marketing strategy clearly didn’t appeal to that crossover audience. The marketing arguably had a lot to do with it.

The Lone Ranger’s publicity looked jumbled: too childish for adults, too grown-up for children

Just take a look at the publicity for Despicable Me 2, which was released the same week and triumphed at the box office. The target audience was clear, whereas, in comparison, The Lone Ranger’s publicity looked jumbled: too childish for adults, too grown-up for children. And on top of that, the trailers were enough to put anyone to sleep. Seriously, try and watch one the entire way through without getting bored (and they’re only two minutes long, which never bodes well for the rest of the film).

The Lone Ranger obviously didn’t appeal to the under-25s category the studio relies on so much for box office success, which could have had something to do with the choice of genre and subject matter. Westerns aren’t exactly the ‘big thing’ right now with young people, few of which would have even known of The Lone Ranger’s place in fictional history, let alone be interested in seeing his revival. Likewise, the ridiculous sci-fi/Civil War epic combination John Carter wasn’t the best idea Disney ever had. Nothing there was exactly screaming ‘blockbuster’ or looked to entice a broad audience.

john-carter-7So why doesn’t Disney stick to the classic, no-nonsense storytelling we know and love it for? Well, even that doesn’t work these days if you throw live actors into the mix, as Disney seems to have developed a habit of taking everyone’s childhood favourites and turning them into live action pointlessness. Tim Burton’s Alice in Wonderland was a critical disappointment, the upcoming Maleficent is an unneeded prequel to Sleeping Beauty and there are now rumours circling of a live action version of the 1966 classic The Jungle Book. That could be the only one worth seeing, if only to see how the hell they manage Baloo.

We’re not ready to forget the charming, fairytale image we have of Disney’s animation background

When it comes to live action, Disney doesn’t seem to have it in the bag just yet, and amongst other things, it might just be because we’re not quite ready to forget the charming, fairytale image we have of the studio’s animation background. When people say “I love Disney,” they’re not thinking of John Carter, but The Lion King, Cinderella and Bambi. It’s not that audiences only want animation – after all, Pirates of the Caribbean and, dare I say it, High School Musical have been huge recent successes. But they do seem to prefer it.

So, if it wants a box office hit, maybe it is for the best that Disney sticks to what it’s good at. Or, at the very least, if it’s going to tackle more live action fare, the studio should stop trying to pull the Johnny Depp card.

 

All images: Walt Disney Studios

Tags: DisneyfilmopinionThe Lone Ranger
Previous Post

The 10 best deleted scenes ever

Next Post

Why Insidious is the best supernatural horror since The Blair Witch

Next Post
Why Insidious is the best supernatural horror since The Blair Witch

Why Insidious is the best supernatural horror since The Blair Witch

Please login to join discussion

KNICKER SNIFFERThe ultimate prank by post

Readers Favourites

Screen Robot Filmcast #4: Bad Neighbours, Blue Ruin and Frank

Review of the Year 2014: Blue Ruin

16th December 2014
155

If You’re Nervous About Your First Time Traveling, Read This

11th July 2017
147
Circling the drain: The waning imagination of the blockbuster

Circling the drain: The waning imagination of the blockbuster

23rd June 2014
211
Screen Robot Filmcast #11: Transformers 4, Boyhood and Begin Again

Screen Robot Filmcast #11: Transformers 4, Boyhood and Begin Again

14th July 2014
132
Syfy Drops New Tremors Series – But here’s the Trailer

Syfy Drops New Tremors Series – But here’s the Trailer

4th May 2018
226
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
Menu
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Copyright © 2020 screenrobot.com

No Result
View All Result
  • Movie News
  • TV News
  • Gaming
    • Xbox Games
  • Streaming
    • Netflix
    • Amazon Prime
    • Now TV
    • Disney Plus
  • Trailers
  • Screen News

© 2020 Screen Robot

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.