Screen Robot
  • Movie News
  • TV News
  • Gaming
    • Xbox Games
  • Streaming
    • Netflix
    • Amazon Prime
    • Now TV
    • Disney Plus
  • Trailers
  • Screen News
No Result
View All Result
  • Movie News
  • TV News
  • Gaming
    • Xbox Games
  • Streaming
    • Netflix
    • Amazon Prime
    • Now TV
    • Disney Plus
  • Trailers
  • Screen News
No Result
View All Result
Screen Robot
No Result
View All Result

Hollywood’s sinister need to dilute great women of literature for the screen

Matthew Byrd by Matthew Byrd
9th July 2019
in Movie News
0 0
0
Hollywood’s sinister need to dilute great women of literature for the screen
0
SHARES
96
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Strong on the page, weak on screen: we examine the?worrying trend of diluting?female characters for cinema.

Female representation in the film industry is shocking. For decades we?ve had to deal with simpering, pathetic female characters who have little purpose other than being there for the male gaze or to be an object of the viewer?s lust. A recent landmark global study backed by the UN has found and exposed “deep-seated discrimination and pervasive stereotyping of women and girls”, including blanket under-representation and widespread hypersexualisation. It seems it’s an issue that won’t go away.?So why exactly do contemporary films fall shy of positive representation? And why are big Hollywood blockbusters the worst culprits?

We’ve seen countless?strong female characters from literature?getting ‘dumbed down’ on their way to the big screen

We’ve seen countless?strong female characters from literature?getting ‘dumbed down’ on their way to the big screen. In Stephen King?s The Shining,?the character Wendy Torrance – played by Shelley Duvall in Stanley Kubrick’s movie adaptation – is trapped in a nightmare situation: shut up in a disused hotel with psychotic husband Jack (Jack Nicholson in the film), she soon begins to realise his mood swings are not simply a case of writer?s block, but indeed something far more sinister.

The film version of The Shining is a Kubrick masterpiece ? the mise en scene, the suspense, the script are all masterfully done – but Kubrick’s Wendy leaves a lot to be desired. Unlike the Wendy in King?s novel,?the Wendy of the movie screams hysterically, cries and runs about the place flapping like a headless chicken. The film can be read as a domestic abuse tale?-?nothing wrong with that interpretation, disturbing though it may be to watch. The real problem is that Wendy in the film is completely unlikable, which problematic considering?she is the victim, treated horribly by her abuser. King himself has called Kubrick’s Wendy “one of the most misogynistic characters ever put on film.”

the shining wendy

In Cary Fukunaga’s 2011 adaptation of?Jane Eyre,?the governess is referred to as “mousy”, where the character in Bronte?s novel is anything but. There seems to be a tension in how Jane Eyre is portrayed on the big screen ? confidence and plainness do not go together in Hollywood. Therefore, Jane has to be portrayed as either ?mousy? or good looking. The book Jane Eyre relies on the reader’s?imagination ? Jane is strong willed, intelligent but plain, but it’s up to the reader to conjure up what she might look like. Films need to appeal to mass audiences in order to make money. Western society is obsessed with beauty and looks. In literature, beauty is more subjective ? it is in the eye of the beholder; it?can be present in qualities such as goodness and intelligence. With?films, it takes a brave producer to cast a ?plain? actress.

In?literature, ‘beauty’ can equate to?goodness or?intelligence. But with?films, it takes a brave producer to cast a ?plain? actress

The Hunger Games franchise’s Katniss Everdeen is a recent exception to the rule; producers have so far avoided sexualising her for the big screen. Although attractive, Katniss’s?strength and resolve is what’s highlighted by the filmmakers. The first film finds her?dressed in brown robes and war gear. In Catching Fire,?Katniss is turned into a peacock, and therefore the spectacle is parodied, for we know Katniss is so much more than a doll. She is adoringly gazed at by her audience in the same way modern society worships female judges on talent shows?for what they wear and what they look like. But Katniss is a rarity.

A weak female characters is?not always necessarily connected with good looks in the movies, though unfortunately they often go hand in hand. To see the spirit of a female character on the page diluted for the screen can be frustrating to watch, but above are just a few examples. The 2011 Jane Eyre?s ‘mousiness’ is?completely at odds with Bronte?s feminist creation. It either shows a complete misunderstanding on the part of producers, or indicates?that there is something more sinister at play in the film industry.

?

Read more: As TV increasingly finds room for women, when will film catch up?

?

Featured image: Universal Pictures

Inset image: Warner Bros

Tags: FemalefeminismfilmmisogynynovelsStephen King
Previous Post

The Tea & Crumpet Filmcast #6: A Walk Among the Tombstones and The Riot Club

Next Post

Can Arnold Schwarzenegger nail a serious role?

Next Post
Can Arnold Schwarzenegger nail a serious role?

Can Arnold Schwarzenegger nail a serious role?

Please login to join discussion

KNICKER SNIFFERThe ultimate prank by post

Readers Favourites

Screen Robot Filmcast #8: 22 Jump Street, Belle and The Sacrament

Screen Robot Filmcast #8: 22 Jump Street, Belle and The Sacrament

9th July 2019
Joaquin Phoenix Joker – First Pictures

Joaquin Phoenix Joker – First Pictures

9th July 2019
Syfy Drops New Tremors Series – But here’s the Trailer

Syfy Drops New Tremors Series – But here’s the Trailer

9th July 2019
Review of the Year 2014: The Drop

Review of the Year 2014: The Drop

9th July 2019
Commitment vs craft: What’s more important to screen acting?

Commitment vs craft: What’s more important to screen acting?

9th July 2019
Screen Robot

Thanks for dropping by, we hope you enjoy your visit. We aim to provide tasty content on everything movie, TV and gaming related. If you want to become one of our super bots and write for the team, then get in touch.

Categories

  • Action Adventure Games
  • Adventure Games
  • Amazon Prime
  • Gaming
  • Movie News
  • Netflix
  • Screen News
  • Survival Horror
  • TV News
  • Uncategorised
  • Xbox Games
  • Xbox Games News

Recent News

Cyberpunk 2077 delayed, again :-(

Cyberpunk 2077 delayed, again :-(

28th October 2020
Al Capone The Movie

Capone The Movie – Tom Hardy

6th May 2020
  • Cart
  • Checkout
  • Cookie Policy
  • My account
  • Privacy Policy
  • Screenrobot
  • Shop
  • Terms and Conditions

© 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Movie News
  • TV News
  • Gaming
    • Xbox Games
  • Streaming
    • Netflix
    • Amazon Prime
    • Now TV
    • Disney Plus
  • Trailers
  • Screen News

© 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In